Facebook Mail RSS Twitter
  • Everyday
    • Education
    • Neighborhood Notes
  • Sports
  • Food & Art
    • Artist Profiles
    • Food Shopping
    • Local Farmers
    • Music
    • Restaurants
  • Community Channels
    • Around the House
      • Home Inspection Services
      • Insurance
        • Insurance Agent – Melanie Bakala
      • Real Estate Agents in Thurston County Covering Olympia Lacey Tumwater Yelm and beyond
    • Business Networking
      • Chamber
        • Chamber of Commerce
      • Economic Development Council
      • Rotary
        • Gateway Rotary
    • Community Talker
      • Instagram Article Feed
    • Health and Wellness
      • Hospital + Medical Center
      • Physical Therapy
    • Media Partners
      • Thurston Community Media
      • NorthAmericaTalk
    • Mentoring (Big Brothers Big Sisters)
    • Movies
    • Olympia Farmers Market
    • City, County and Government Information
      • People in Public Service
      • City of Lacey, Washington
      • City of Olympia, Washington
      • City of Tumwater, Washington
      • City of Yelm, Washington
      • City, County and Port Meetings
      • Port of Olympia
      • Thurston County Washington
    • Senior Life
      • Cemetery Products
      • In-Home Care
      • Senior Services for South Sound
    • Services
      • Auto Repair
      • Pet Emergency
    • South Puget Sound Community College
    • Thurston County Podcast
  • Featured Businesses
    • Around The House
    • Health Care
    • Local Retail Shops
    • Services
    • Women in Business
  • History
  • Photos
    • Community Events
    • Local Attractions
    • Sporting Events
  • Non-Profits
  • LocalTalk
  • Activities
    • Dogs & Pets
    • Family & Kids
    • Indoor
    • Outdoor
    • Gardening
    • Outdoor Recreation
    • Biking
    • Camping
    • Hiking
    • Running
    • Parks and Beaches
    • Thrifty Thurston
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Post an Event
  • Calendar
  • Travel
    • Day Trips
    • Overnight Trips
  • Podcast
Search
Tuesday, July 8, 2025
  • About
    • Story
    • Team
    • Company News
    • Contact
    • Terms of Use
  • Advertise
    • How our Olympia advertising works
    • Launch a Campaign
    • Grow your Audience
    • Measure the Results
    • Company News
    • Contact
  • Events
    • Community Calendar
    • Articles
    • List an Event
  • I5 Traffic Cameras
Facebook Mail RSS Twitter
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
ThurstonTalk
  • Everyday
    • AllEducationNeighborhood Notes
      Humanitarian and influencer Kwabi Amoah-Forson stands at a podium with staff from Evergreen State College sitting behind him. a Banner says "Congratulations Class of 2025 - Evergreen" on the wall behind him

      The Evergreen State College Alumnus Kwabi Amoah-Forson Tells 2025 Graduates to…

      a woman leans over an older youth in a wheelchair, there are other adults and kids in a playground in the background

      South Sound Parent to Parent Invites Community to Join Them in…

      a group of high school students smile for a photo standing side by side, each with a medal around their neck

      71 North Thurston Public Schools Students Earn Seal of Biliteracy This…

      Tenino Moves Historic Train Depot, 1975

  • Sports
  • Food & Art
    • AllArtist ProfilesFood ShoppingLocal FarmersMusicRestaurants
      Rendering of a spacious cafeteria-style building with people sitting and walking around

      New Restaurant in Downtown Olympia Opening Soon

      Unique Pop-Up Vendor Brings Dirty Sodas to Olympia Area

      a bottle of Woodborne Spirits vodka with chantrelle mushrooms lying around it

      From Forest to Bottle: Woodborne Spirits turns Chanterelles into Award-Winning Gin…

      a bowl of bao with a red spoon with broth held over it. A bao is being held above the spoon with chopsticks

      Get Your Bao Some Bao in Thurston County: New Dough Zone…

  • Community Channels
    • Around the House
      • Home Inspection Services
      • Insurance
        • Insurance Agent – Melanie Bakala
      • Real Estate Agents in Thurston County Covering Olympia Lacey Tumwater Yelm and beyond
    • Business Networking
      • Chamber
        • Chamber of Commerce
      • Economic Development Council
      • Rotary
        • Gateway Rotary
    • Community Talker
      • Instagram Article Feed
    • Health and Wellness
      • Hospital + Medical Center
      • Physical Therapy
    • Media Partners
      • Thurston Community Media
      • NorthAmericaTalk
    • Mentoring (Big Brothers Big Sisters)
    • Movies
    • Olympia Farmers Market
    • City, County and Government Information
      • People in Public Service
      • City of Lacey, Washington
      • City of Olympia, Washington
      • City of Tumwater, Washington
      • City of Yelm, Washington
      • City, County and Port Meetings
      • Port of Olympia
      • Thurston County Washington
    • Senior Life
      • Cemetery Products
      • In-Home Care
      • Senior Services for South Sound
    • Services
      • Auto Repair
      • Pet Emergency
    • South Puget Sound Community College
    • Thurston County Podcast
  • Featured Businesses
    • AllAround The HouseHealth CareLocal Retail ShopsServicesWomen in Business
      An Intercity Transit bus on a road with green grass next to it a tree full of cherry blossoms

      Intercity Transit Embarks on Year-Long Process to Redesign Bus System Serving…

      a girl sits at a table on a laptop, a man is next her holding a cellphone and across the table is a young boy holding a tablet

      Comcast Unveils Simpler, Predictable Internet Pricing: What It Means for Thurston…

      outside of the WSECU Hawks Prairie branch with the letters "WSECU" in white on the front and empty parking spaces in front.

      WSECU Guides Members Through Life’s Major Financial Events With In-Person Banking…

      A Multi-Pronged Approach at Penrose Physical Therapy Keeps Patient Healthy and…

  • History
    • Tenino Moves Historic Train Depot, 1975

      Arleen Webb Crooks Helped Make Olympia a Better Place

      Olympia History: Remembering the Daylight Bakery

      The Marie Bed & Breakfast in olympia

      From Historic Charm to Cozy Retreat: The Story of Our Victorian…

      People in Public Service: Cassandra Messegee Brown, Thurston County Superintendent of…

  • Photos
    • AllCommunity EventsLocal AttractionsSporting Events
      capital city pride

      Thousands Gather in Olympia to Celebrate Capital City Pride 2018

      procession species olympia

      Luminary Procession 2018: Lighting Up the Rainy Night in Downtown Olympia

      snowy winter scene

      ThurstonTalk Readers Capture Christmas Snow

      Twinklefest 2017

      Twinklefest 2017 Window Displays

  • Non-Profits
    • a woman leans over an older youth in a wheelchair, there are other adults and kids in a playground in the background

      South Sound Parent to Parent Invites Community to Join Them in…

      Chris Hyde stands in a kitchen, writing something on a notepad, three woman stand behind him behind a counter

      The Food Source Foundation and ‘Hometown Hero’ Finalist in Olympia Heat…

      a large group of men and woman with a couple kids post for a photo, four are kneeling, the rest are standing. They are in front of a pop up tent that says 'TOGETHER!" with three hand prints next to it One woman is holding a gift basket

      The League of Foundations Unites Three Local Nonprofits to Extend their…

      a man holds a child with a woman standing next to hem and a boat in the background

      South Sound Parent to Parent is a Resource Helping Families With…

      Komachin Middle School Future Business Leaders of America standing behind a long table with food in bins

      Matthew Klifman Takes Over as All Kids Win Board Chair

  • LocalTalk
    • Jacob Garsez poses for a photo in a red Saints jacket with his arms crossed in front of his chest. The Saint Martin's Trojan logo is behind him on a large glass window

      Saint Martin’s University Names Jacob Garsez As New Head Baseball Coach

      Lake Cushman

      Bear Gulch Fire Limits Access to Lake Cushman Corridor (FS-24) and…

      State Awards Grants in Thurston County to Improve Outdoor Recreation and…

      No One Dies Alone Volunteer Program Launches July 1

      Leave Fireworks at Home and Be Careful With Campfires While Celebrating…

  • Activities
    • AllDogs & PetsFamily & KidsIndoorOutdoorGardeningOutdoor RecreationBikingCampingHikingRunningParks and BeachesThrifty Thurston
      People on the shore at Tolmie State Beach during low tide, with an island in the distance and clouds in the sky

      State Park Near Olympia-Lacey That’s Great for Picnicking, Walking and More

      a man fishes in a small boat on Lake Sylvia, trees cover the bank on the other side

      Visit Washington Coast’s Lake Sylvia

      Polson Logging Company steam engine pulling the Mt. Rainier Scenic train through the forest

      Mt. Rainier Scenic Railroad Still in Operation After Fire, Take a…

      young boys and girls in t-shirts and shorts stand in a line on a field, the hands of an adult are seen handing the first two kids orange balls. The kid at the front of the line is throwing her ball.,

      New Engaging Youth Summer Camps Have Sports, STEAM, Coding, Music, Water…

  • Events
    • a group of people stand next to a red motorcycle, two of them are holding a giant check.

      An Exciting Summer Is Ahead at Mason Health, With Installation of…

      long sticks with salmon attached them over an open flam. A black belt runs in front of the fire pit that says Lucky Eagle Casino Resort

      Heat up Your Family’s Summer at the Barbecue Festival in Yelm

      a man speaking into a microphone with a young boy next to him at West Bay Park, the new totem carving is in the background

      The West Olympia Rotary Commemorates 50th Anniversary Through ‘Life Is Water’…

      an artist sits at a table with her paintings on display

      Shelton Art Walk Returns in 2025 with a Celebration of Art,…

      black night sky with two fireworks going off in red and green

      2025 July 4th Fireworks in Thurston County

    • Calendar
    • Post an Event
  • Calendar
  • Travel
    • Day Trips
    • Overnight Trips
  • Podcast
Home History Who Killed Quiemuth?

Who Killed Quiemuth?

By
Emmett O'Connell
-

Share via:

0 Shares
  • More
FacebookTweetPin

It’s late fall in 1856. The Puget Sound War between American settlers and the region’s Native American tribes was wrapping up. Chief Leschi of the Nisqually had been captured by territorial officials and taken to Olympia. A mob had formed outside the building where he was being kept and he was quickly moved to Steilacoom to await trial.

sunset airTo avoid capture, Leschi’s brother, Quiemuth, decided to turn himself in. James Longmire and Van Ogle accompanied Quiemuth to Olympia from Yelm. The group arrived in Olympia well after dark. Territorial Governor Isaac Stevens, who gave them a place to sleep in his office, met them.

In the early morning, Quiemuth was murdered. According to Ogle, the crime that was committed was this: Quiemuth was first shot, and when he tried to chase the attempted murderer through the door, someone stabbed him to death.

Longmire took chase as well, and was faced with almost 20 people milling in the early morning outside the office. Who in that crowd killed Quiemuth?

History’s Suspect: Joe Bunting

quiemuth history
Joseph Bunting (here spelled Bunton) was suspected, but not convicted of the murder of Quiemuth. Photo credit: Olympia Pioneer and Democrat.

The only suspect directly named by history was Joseph Bunting, a 23-year-old farmer who had likely come to Puget Sound from New England. He was a very new father, his first child being born only days before Quiemuth’s murder.

His wife was the daughter of James McAllister, a farmer who had been killed during the Puget Sound War. That death of the family patriarch gave Bunting motive to murder Quiemuth.

But, the only court to ever look into this murder didn’t think Bunting did it. Again, history paints a story of the community closing ranks around Bunting – that even though he really did kill Quiemuth, no one was brave enough to implicate him.

But, it is likely that Bunting just ended up being history’s suspect, because there are at least two other men who were just as likely to have been there that night. And, their personal histories make them much more likely killers.

The Ringleader: George McAllister

quiemuth history
Quiemuth was the brother of Chief Leschi. Photo credit: Washington State Historical Society.

James McAllister’s own son was only 19 when Quiemuth was shot and stabbed. Who else other than his own son would have more reason to seek vengeance?

Contemporary newspapers reported that in the years following the Puget Sound War and Quiemuth’s murder, McAllister had a hand in killing at least two more Indians. He would blame both for being involved in his father’s death.

The most well documented murder of an Indian that McAllister publicly took credit for was that of Too-a-pi-ti. While stories vary, even McAllister’s own version includes him and a group (including Bunting, another man Jim Riley and at least one other man) gunning down Too-a-pi-ti as he ran. In another version, the group shot Too-a-pi-ti as he led them back to his camp.

Either way, George McAllister’s acts years after the end of the Puget Sound War and the murder of Quiemuth, and the more direct motive of vengeance, make him at least as likely a culprit as Bunting.

Olympia’s first big time criminal: Jim Riley

quiemuth history
The site of Quiemuth’s murder lay mid block on Capitol Way between State and Olympia (marked as 2nd Ave here).

At every step of the way, one addition names pops up continually: Jim Riley. In the early years, Riley seems to be just another member of the McAllister gang. He was mentioned often and possibly the one who put a bullet in Too-a-pi-ti’s back, but rarely stood out.

As the years wore on and the history of the Puget Sound War faded, the vengeance business slowed down. Riley distinguished himself as a classic criminal. While others in the McAllister family orbit probably have at least vengeance on their mind, Riley was simply a common criminal.

By 1861, his list of crimes included “brutal” assault, rape, larceny, drunkenness and disorderly conduct. And, by now, the county sheriff was after him and Riley was set to leave down and disappear in the mines east of the mountains.

But, before that, he prepared for one last violent spree, which ended up including the murder of an Indian and yet another “brutal” assault. He smashed a man’s head in with a rock and somehow the man survived.

Eventually, the law caught up with Riley. Captured and sustaining a gunshot wound in his leg for trying to run from the sheriff, Riley did not give up. He hobbled around on crutches apparently longer than he needed to. And, then, when his guards were distracted (and he was not otherwise secured) he left his crutches and disappeared for good into the woods and possibly off to the mines.

There is a record of a Jim Riley committing a murder in King County a few years later, but Riley as a historic figure, disappeared through the trees in 1861.

We’ll never actually know who killed Quiemuth. While that murder may be Olympia’s first notorious killing, it wasn’t in fact the first documented killing in Olympia as an American city. In fact, that goes (almost fittingly) to another man, Robert Brainard, who strangled an Indian in 1854.

There was a lot of violence in these early years. While it seems easy to pin the blame on history’s culprit, there were certainly plenty of violent men nearby that could have equally played a hand.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
FacebookTweetPin

Share via:

0 Shares
  • More
Previous articleOlympia Dancers Swing the Night Away
Next articleAny Time is Reading Buddy Time
Emmett O'Connell

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Tenino Moves Historic Train Depot, 1975

Arleen Webb Crooks Helped Make Olympia a Better Place

Olympia History: Remembering the Daylight Bakery

Upcoming Events

Jul
8
Tue
8:30 am Crusader Camps-Sports Camp @ Evergreen Christian School
Crusader Camps-Sports Camp @ Evergreen Christian School
Jul 8 @ 8:30 am – 4:30 pm
Crusader Camps-Sports Camp @ Evergreen Christian School
Join us at camp this summer at Evergreen Christian School. Camps facilitated by educators and open to students age 3 – 12. Low counselor to camper ratio. It is going to be LOTS of fun![...]
View Calendar
Add
  • Add to Timely Calendar
  • Add to Google
  • Add to Outlook
  • Add to Apple Calendar
  • Add to other calendar
  • Export to XML

Local Community Sponsors

Local Community Sponsors

Business

An Intercity Transit bus on a road with green grass next to it a tree full of cherry blossoms

Intercity Transit Embarks on Year-Long Process to Redesign Bus System Serving...

Intercity Transit is embarking on a year-long process to update its bus system serving the Olympia, Lacey, Tumwater and Yelm areas. This exciting endeavor...
a girl sits at a table on a laptop, a man is next her holding a cellphone and across the table is a young boy holding a tablet

Comcast Unveils Simpler, Predictable Internet Pricing: What It Means for Thurston...

outside of the WSECU Hawks Prairie branch with the letters "WSECU" in white on the front and empty parking spaces in front.

WSECU Guides Members Through Life’s Major Financial Events With In-Person Banking...

A Multi-Pronged Approach at Penrose Physical Therapy Keeps Patient Healthy and...

an updated kitchen and dining area with light wood floors, white cabinets and white counters

Family-Owned Olympia Builder Will Take Your New Home or Renovation Project...

Trending Now

Rendering of a spacious cafeteria-style building with people sitting and walking around

New Restaurant in Downtown Olympia Opening Soon

Humanitarian and influencer Kwabi Amoah-Forson stands at a podium with staff from Evergreen State College sitting behind him. a Banner says "Congratulations Class of 2025 - Evergreen" on the wall behind him

The Evergreen State College Alumnus Kwabi Amoah-Forson Tells 2025 Graduates to...

An Intercity Transit bus on a road with green grass next to it a tree full of cherry blossoms

Intercity Transit Embarks on Year-Long Process to Redesign Bus System Serving...

Editor Picks

an artist sits at a table with her paintings on display

Shelton Art Walk Returns in 2025 with a Celebration of Art,...

young boys and girls in t-shirts and shorts stand in a line on a field, the hands of an adult are seen handing the first two kids orange balls. The kid at the front of the line is throwing her ball.,

New Engaging Youth Summer Camps Have Sports, STEAM, Coding, Music, Water...

Oksana Skillings in her classroom showing huge playing cards to the seated students

North Thurston Public Schools Celebrates Educators Who Embody Joy of Learning 

Recent Posts

  • Saint Martin’s University Names Jacob Garsez As New Head Baseball Coach
  • Bear Gulch Fire Limits Access to Lake Cushman Corridor (FS-24) and Staircase Area
  • Intercity Transit Embarks on Year-Long Process to Redesign Bus System Serving Olympia, Lacey, Tumwater and Yelm Areas
  • State Awards Grants in Thurston County to Improve Outdoor Recreation and Wildlife Habitat
  • The Evergreen State College Alumnus Kwabi Amoah-Forson Tells 2025 Graduates to Remain Hopeful and Empower People in Need
ABOUT US
ThurstonTalk is a community social network delivering positive stories about what it’s like to live, work and play in Thurston County Washington, including Olympia, Lacey, Tumwater, Yelm, Tenino and the surrounding area. Advertise with ThurstonTalk. Brand your business and tell your story to your target market.
Contact us: info@thurstontalk.com
FOLLOW US
Facebook Mail RSS Twitter
  • About
    • Story
    • Team
    • Company News
    • Contact
    • Terms of Use
  • Advertise
    • How our Olympia advertising works
    • Launch a Campaign
    • Grow your Audience
    • Measure the Results
    • Company News
    • Contact
  • Events
    • Community Calendar
    • Articles
    • List an Event
  • I5 Traffic Cameras
© ThurstonTalk, Inc.
Share via
Facebook
X (Twitter)
LinkedIn
Mix
Email
Print
Copy Link
Powered by Social Snap
Copy link
CopyCopied
Powered by Social Snap