• Everyday
    • Education
    • Neighborhood Notes
  • Sports
  • Food & Art
    • Artist Profiles
    • Food Shopping
    • Local Farmers
    • Music
    • Restaurants
  • Community Channels
    • Around the House
      • Home Inspection Services
      • Insurance
        • Insurance Agent – Melanie Bakala
      • Real Estate Agents in Thurston County Covering Olympia Lacey Tumwater Yelm and beyond
    • Business Networking
      • Chamber
        • Chamber of Commerce
      • Economic Development Council
      • Rotary
        • Gateway Rotary
    • Community Talker
      • Instagram Article Feed
    • Health and Wellness
      • Hospital + Medical Center
      • Physical Therapy
    • Media Partners
      • Thurston Community Media
      • NorthAmericaTalk
    • Mentoring (Big Brothers Big Sisters)
    • Movies
    • Olympia Farmers Market
    • City, County and Government Information
      • People in Public Service
      • City of Lacey, Washington
      • City of Olympia, Washington
      • City of Tumwater, Washington
      • City of Yelm, Washington
      • City, County and Port Meetings
      • Port of Olympia
      • Thurston County Washington
    • Senior Life
      • Cemetery Products
      • In-Home Care
      • Senior Services for South Sound
    • Services
      • Auto Repair
      • Pet Emergency
    • South Puget Sound Community College
    • Thurston County Podcast
  • Featured Businesses
    • Around The House
    • Health Care
    • Local Retail Shops
    • Services
    • Women in Business
  • History
  • Photos
    • Community Events
    • Local Attractions
    • Sporting Events
  • Non-Profits
  • LocalTalk
  • Activities
    • Dogs & Pets
    • Family & Kids
    • Indoor
    • Outdoor
    • Gardening
    • Outdoor Recreation
    • Biking
    • Camping
    • Hiking
    • Running
    • Parks and Beaches
    • Thrifty Thurston
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Post an Event
  • Calendar
  • Travel
    • Day Trips
    • Overnight Trips
  • Podcast
Search
Wednesday, September 27, 2023
  • About
    • Story
    • Team
    • Company News
    • Contact
    • Terms of Use
  • Advertise
    • How our Olympia advertising works
    • Launch a Campaign
    • Grow your Audience
    • Measure the Results
    • Company News
    • Contact
  • Events
    • Community Calendar
    • Articles
    • List an Event
  • I5 Traffic Cameras
ThurstonTalk
  • Everyday
    • AllEducationNeighborhood Notes
      Shellica Trevino headshot

      Meet New Boys & Girls Clubs of Thurston County CEO Shellica…

      White Intercity Transit Village Van with Ici LeMay in the driver's seat.

      Intercity Transit’s Village Vans Program Trains Volunteers for Life Changing Careers

      Large group of woman, some sitting and some standing, inside the Olympia School of Advanced Skincare

      The Olympia School of Advanced Skincare Is Set To Help South…

      Make Harbor Heights in Olympia Your Home and Experience Stress-Free Travel…

  • Sports
  • Food & Art
    • AllArtist ProfilesFood ShoppingLocal FarmersMusicRestaurants

      Olympia Pastry Café Owner Phoebe Martinson Competes in 2023 Food Network…

      The History of the Olympic Grill, Olympia’s Mid-Century Family Restaurant

      close up of a red apple on a branch with leaves

      Where To Go Apple Picking Near Olympia

      Olympia Symphony Presents Groundbreaking American Premiere

  • Community Channels
    • Around the House
      • Home Inspection Services
      • Insurance
        • Insurance Agent – Melanie Bakala
      • Real Estate Agents in Thurston County Covering Olympia Lacey Tumwater Yelm and beyond
    • Business Networking
      • Chamber
        • Chamber of Commerce
      • Economic Development Council
      • Rotary
        • Gateway Rotary
    • Community Talker
      • Instagram Article Feed
    • Health and Wellness
      • Hospital + Medical Center
      • Physical Therapy
    • Media Partners
      • Thurston Community Media
      • NorthAmericaTalk
    • Mentoring (Big Brothers Big Sisters)
    • Movies
    • Olympia Farmers Market
    • City, County and Government Information
      • People in Public Service
      • City of Lacey, Washington
      • City of Olympia, Washington
      • City of Tumwater, Washington
      • City of Yelm, Washington
      • City, County and Port Meetings
      • Port of Olympia
      • Thurston County Washington
    • Senior Life
      • Cemetery Products
      • In-Home Care
      • Senior Services for South Sound
    • Services
      • Auto Repair
      • Pet Emergency
    • South Puget Sound Community College
    • Thurston County Podcast
  • Featured Businesses
    • AllAround The HouseHealth CareLocal Retail ShopsServicesWomen in Business
      Stink bug on a stick

      Prevent Stink Bugs and Other Overwintering Pests from Invading Your Home…

      photo of an empty room with a textured vinyl plank floor that looks like wood

      SPF Construction Recommends Durable, Waterproof, Scratch-Resistant Laminate Flooring

      If You Become Pregnant, Put Your Trust in Providence Swedish

      Black and white photo of the Gull Harbor Mercantile from a newspaper

      Olympia’s Gull Harbor Mercantile: An Enduring Beacon of Community

  • History
    • The History of the Olympic Grill, Olympia’s Mid-Century Family Restaurant

      Black and white photo of the Gull Harbor Mercantile from a newspaper

      Olympia’s Gull Harbor Mercantile: An Enduring Beacon of Community

      People in Public Service: Olympia High School’s Eli Loomis

      Cooking With ‘Cook’s Tour’ in the 1960s, Yvonne Hull’s Olympia TV…

      colorful drawing of a woman in a red dress, her head wrapped with a white and gold head piece and a child swaddled against her back, in the background in a ruined city. Words read: 'Lest the perish'

      Supporting Near East Relief in 1920s Thurston County

  • Photos
    • AllCommunity EventsLocal AttractionsSporting Events
      capital city pride

      Thousands Gather in Olympia to Celebrate Capital City Pride 2018

      procession species olympia

      Luminary Procession 2018: Lighting Up the Rainy Night in Downtown Olympia

      snowy winter scene

      ThurstonTalk Readers Capture Christmas Snow

      Twinklefest 2017

      Twinklefest 2017 Window Displays

  • Non-Profits
    • Shellica Trevino headshot

      Meet New Boys & Girls Clubs of Thurston County CEO Shellica…

      child sitting on the floor in a house playing with wood blocks

      Autism Program Expands at South Sound Parent to Parent

      Mission Nonprofit Spotlight: Crisis Clinic

      Why South Puget Sound Community College Alumni Success Stories Matter

      Three women, two dressed up as superheroes, post for a photo behind a table with a fabric on it and a tablecloth that says 'Zap; 'Boom' on it

      Focus on Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Benefits Community through South Sound…

  • LocalTalk
    • Razor clam

      WDFW Approves Four Days of Coastal Razor Clam Digs Beginning September…

      Fall Into Sweater Weather TOGETHER!

      olympia sunset

      Plum Street YMCA Mural Receives Arts Walk Innovation Award

      volunteers-planting-oyster-grow-bags-on-the-beach-in-budd-inlet-smaller

      Olympia Oyster Planting Volunteers Needed this September and October

      UPDATE: Recreational Fires Now Allowed in Thurston County

  • Activities
    • AllDogs & PetsFamily & KidsIndoorOutdoorGardeningOutdoor RecreationBikingCampingHikingRunningParks and BeachesThrifty Thurston

      Fall Hiking Near Olympia

      A kid on an indoor rock climbing wall with kids on the ground in a line

      Affordable and Fun Youth Experience Classes at South Sound YMCA

      kayaker in the water paddling to Squaxin Park

      Easy Sea Kayaking Adventure in Olympia’s Budd Bay: Swantown Marina to…

      2023 Pumpkin Patches and Corn Mazes in Olympia and Throughout Thurston…

  • Events
    • The Washington Center Spices Up Your Friday Night with a Little…

      A kid on an indoor rock climbing wall with kids on the ground in a line

      Affordable and Fun Youth Experience Classes at South Sound YMCA

      Procession of the Species Will Return in 2024

      Providence Swedish Presents Community Talk on Behavioral Health and Addiction Services

      Women looking at products in paper cups on a wooden shelf.

      Showcase Your Business at Lacey South Sound Chamber’s Annual Winter Fest

    • Calendar
    • Post an Event
  • Calendar
  • Travel
    • Day Trips
    • Overnight Trips
  • Podcast
Home Don't Miss History of the Messy Olympia/Tumwater City Border

History of the Messy Olympia/Tumwater City Border

By
Emmett O'Connell

Share via:

98 Shares
  • More
FacebookTweetPin

The border between Olympia and Tumwater just north of North Street is a jumbled mess. While municipal borders aren’t often clean lines, this particular example is an extreme case.

tumwater auto spaOn some streets, houses switch between cities as you move from neighbor to neighbor. What this jumbled map represents is a few months between 1949 and 1950 of aggressive civic plans and divergent wishes of neighbors about what city they wanted to live in.

This particular part of Olympia and Tumwater had been fairly rural until just about World War II. At the start of the war, many of the streets we now see in that neighborhood had been laid out, but they were mostly empty of homes. Those homes that were built were clustered along the northern end of the neighborhood along Carlyon Street.

olympia tumwater city line
In 1940, most of the North/Carlyon neighborhood was not yet built out. Photo courtesy: USGS.

Soon after the war, the still unincorporated area began sprouting a thicker neighborhood.

Then, in the summer of 1949 a small skirmish between Olympia and Tumwater started as each city began scooping up parcels and houses along the newly laid out streets.

The procedure to become annexed into either city was for residents and property owners to draw a line on a map and get as many people inside that area to sign a petition. The owners of sixty percent of the assessed land value (roughly) in the area to be annexed needed to sign before a city could consider expanding city boundaries.

This issue is typically settled because newer neighborhoods were usually annexed before construction. In that way a developer could bring their entire project into the city. But, because the North/Carlyon neighborhood had already begun growing, each neighbor could essentially choose between either city.

olympia tumwater city line
Three houses in two cities. On Hawthorn Street, three houses are in two cities – Olympia, Tumwater and Olympia. Photo courtesy: Emmett O’Connell.

Both cities quickly began considering and passing sometimes overlapping annexations. A house that was included in one annexation petition, and approved by one city, would be included in a competing annexation agreement by the other.

Tensions between leaders of either city and neighbors were high. From the Olympia News in August 1949:

The Tumwater hall Monday was almost crowded – literally – to the rafters, and many of the people present had to have chairs brought in so they could sit in the hall outside. Others had to stand.

Each resident and homeowner had to weigh the cost (taxes, fire insurance) of being in either city with what community they identified with most.

One local resident even claimed that the annexation debate cost him his job. “I got into a tangle with Bud Dawley over the annexation question,” Verne Bacharach, formerly of the state tax commission charged. “He said he’d have me fired and he did.”

olympia tumwater city line
The jumbled lines on the map show the border in the North/Carlyon neighborhood between homes in Olympia and Tumwater. Photo courtesy: City of Olympia.

His target responded: “Annexations didn’t have a thing to do with it…”

Some of the annexation petitions ended up in court and at one point the county sheriff was called in to help mediate the situation. The sheriff chaired a special meeting just between the neighbors, not involving any representatives of the city. But, even that neighbor meeting failed to tamp out the flames of quick annexation as the cities quickly gobbled up petitions throughout the fall, winter and spring.

All together, Olympia on its own considered and passed nine different annexation petitions for property in the neighborhood between September 1949 and May 1950. Several of these ended up in court before being ironed out.

Even the Olympia Brewery, with its home in Tumwater and the namesake of Olympia, felt it needed to speak up. A special advertisement paid for by the brewery called for peace:

One day someone suggested that perhaps greater benefit could be gained by consolidation or annexation…

One misunderstanding led to another, neighbor was pitted against neighbor, friend against friend, toes were stepped on, tempers strained, and some claim that even the dogs, seeming to sense the commotion, barked at each other until near pandemonium reigned.

Contrary to some unfounded rumors, the Olympia Brewing Company will neither stand to lose nor gain a thing from any decision reached… We have employees and management staff residing in all three areas and we respect their feelings and opinions…

Coloring the neighborhood debate was the expansionist attitudes of either city. In the same year, Olympia was also considering sizeable annexations along both the west and east sides of the city.

Tumwater was on a more aggressive annexation binge along its borders, bringing in over 600 city blocks in one week. For this sudden expansion, Tumwater looked away from Olympia, but in every other direction (south, east and west) instead.

“The motive behind these annexations is the rapid forthcoming development in all parts of the newly annexed areas and the overwhelming desire to avail the new areas of water, fire and street facilities of Tumwater,” the Tumwater mayor said. Tumwater wanted to grow.

As 1950 wore on, the number of non-annexed lots in the disputed area quickly declined. The last hold out finally came into Olympia in the last 1960s. But, tensions over the border dissipated over time.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
FacebookTweetPin

Share via:

98 Shares
  • More
Previous articleLeah Irwin and Sharon Baker Provide Hand-Knit Hats and Scarves for People in Need
Next articleCut Loose and Go Hog Wild at Quinault Beach Resort and Casino
Emmett O'Connell

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

The Washington Center Spices Up Your Friday Night with a Little Six Appeal

The History of the Olympic Grill, Olympia’s Mid-Century Family Restaurant

Procession of the Species Will Return in 2024

Upcoming Events

Sep
27
Wed
9:00 am South Puget Sound New Horizons B... @ Capital Vision Christian Church
South Puget Sound New Horizons B... @ Capital Vision Christian Church
Sep 27 @ 9:00 am – 9:45 am
South Puget Sound New Horizons Band New Beginnings Instrumental Music Class @ Capital Vision Christian Church
Attention Senior Musicians — and Wanna Be Musicians! The South Puget Sound New Horizons Band, a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization, is a group of musicians age 50 and older that formed to provide an opportunity to[...]
10:00 am How Many Stars are in the Jar? @ Lacey Timberland Library
How Many Stars are in the Jar? @ Lacey Timberland Library
Sep 27 @ 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
How Many Stars are in the Jar? @ Lacey Timberland Library
Stop by the Lacey Library during open hours anytime between September 15 and October 14 and try to estimate the number of origami paper stars we’ve captured in our jar! When you submit your guess,[...]
10:00 am Master Gardener Foundation Plan... @ MG Nursery at Yauger Park
Master Gardener Foundation Plan... @ MG Nursery at Yauger Park
Sep 27 @ 10:00 am – 1:00 pm
Master Gardener Foundation  Plant Sale @ MG Nursery at Yauger Park
Are your prunders dull? Our tool team will be there to clean and sharpen up to 3 tools per person. No charge! New plants are arriving every week. We offer a large selection of quality[...]
11:30 am South Sound Connections @ Indian Summer Golf and Country Club
South Sound Connections @ Indian Summer Golf and Country Club
Sep 27 @ 11:30 am – 1:00 pm
South Sound Connections @ Indian Summer Golf and Country Club
We welcome our Chamber members and guests to join South Sound Connections for a fun and educational networking group. This will be a great opportunity to brand your business, meet business professionals, and learn how[...]
2:30 pm Open Book Club @ Lacey Timberland Library
Open Book Club @ Lacey Timberland Library
Sep 27 @ 2:30 pm – 3:30 pm
Open Book Club @ Lacey Timberland Library
Come join other book lovers for a discussion of what we’ve been reading lately. Share your likes & dislikes, and find new reads! Made possible by support from our Friends of the Library. / El[...]
View Calendar

Local Community Sponsors

Local Community Sponsors

Business

Stink bug on a stick

Prevent Stink Bugs and Other Overwintering Pests from Invading Your Home...

Fall brings with it apple cider, pumpkins and…stink bugs! Along with other overwintering pests, including boxelder bugs and western conifer seed...
photo of an empty room with a textured vinyl plank floor that looks like wood

SPF Construction Recommends Durable, Waterproof, Scratch-Resistant Laminate Flooring

If You Become Pregnant, Put Your Trust in Providence Swedish

Black and white photo of the Gull Harbor Mercantile from a newspaper

Olympia’s Gull Harbor Mercantile: An Enduring Beacon of Community

Providence Swedish: Help Prevent Death by Suicide by Watching for the...

Trending Now

Stink bug on a stick

Prevent Stink Bugs and Other Overwintering Pests from Invading Your Home...

olympia sunset

Plum Street YMCA Mural Receives Arts Walk Innovation Award

Shellica Trevino headshot

Meet New Boys & Girls Clubs of Thurston County CEO Shellica...

Editor Picks

Olympia Pastry Café Owner Phoebe Martinson Competes in 2023 Food Network...

Stink bug on a stick

Prevent Stink Bugs and Other Overwintering Pests from Invading Your Home...

The History of the Olympic Grill, Olympia’s Mid-Century Family Restaurant

Recent Posts

  • Olympia Pastry Café Owner Phoebe Martinson Competes in 2023 Food Network Halloween Baking Championship
  • WDFW Approves Four Days of Coastal Razor Clam Digs Beginning September 29, Digging at Mocrocks Is Postponed
  • Fall Hiking Near Olympia
  • Fall Into Sweater Weather TOGETHER!
  • Plum Street YMCA Mural Receives Arts Walk Innovation Award
ABOUT US
ThurstonTalk is a community social network delivering positive stories about what it’s like to live, work and play in Thurston County Washington, including Olympia, Lacey, Tumwater, Yelm, Tenino and the surrounding area. Advertise with ThurstonTalk. Brand your business and tell your story to your target market.
Contact us: info@thurstontalk.com
FOLLOW US
  • About
    • Story
    • Team
    • Company News
    • Contact
    • Terms of Use
  • Advertise
    • How our Olympia advertising works
    • Launch a Campaign
    • Grow your Audience
    • Measure the Results
    • Company News
    • Contact
  • Events
    • Community Calendar
    • Articles
    • List an Event
  • I5 Traffic Cameras
© ThurstonTalk, Inc.
Share via
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Mix
Email
Print
Copy Link
Powered by Social Snap
Copy link
CopyCopied
Powered by Social Snap